IVA or Debt Management?
Deciding between an IVA or debt management plan can be a daunting task and there is no right or wrong answer. However, both can be a good option in different situations therefore knowing the pros and cons of each will help you make a more informed decision.
The first criteria which will make your choice extremely easy is that you can apply for an Individual Voluntary Agreement only if you have a minimum of £15,000 in debt to at least 3 creditors while a Debt Management Plan limits you to a minimum £8,000 in debt to 2 creditors.
One of the most important differences between the two, especially if you qualify for both, is that with an IVA you will be debt free in five years, regardless of how much you have paid off, whereas with a debt management plan you can end up paying it off for the rest of your life if the monthly repayments are small. Also, the fact that an IVA is a legally binding agreement means that your creditors cannot back out of it any time they feel like it, while a debt management plan carries little judicial weight. However, this legal character of an IVA means that if you cannot keep up with payments then you will most likely end up being made bankrupt. There is a very fine line between the good and the bad in this case.
On the other hand with an IVA you will be making monthly payments that can vary according to your earnings, in other words the more you earn the more you will be paying, whereas with a debt management plan you pay only the amount you want and feel can afford which is then fixed for the duration. One big problem with a debt management plan is that most of the companies who help you organise it require that you have an income and own your home which will be used as surety against your debts, while an IVA will protect large assets such as your residence.
Depending on your situation both plans can be a good choice. However, if you are in deep debt then maybe an IVA is your best option so that you can see the light at the end of the five year tunnel.